advice

Solar Battery or Hot Water Diverter: Which Do You Need?

Both stop your spare solar going to the grid for less than you pay for it. How each one works, which homes suit which, and when the answer is both or neither.

By Lumen Solar

On a bright day most solar systems make more than the house is using. That surplus goes to the grid, and your supplier pays you an export rate for it, usually well below what you pay for electricity.

There are two common ways to keep more of it: a battery or a hot water diverter. They solve the same problem in different ways.

How a hot water diverter works

A diverter watches what your house is sending to the grid. When there’s a surplus, it sends that power to your immersion heater instead, turning it up and down so it uses only spare solar and never draws from the grid.

The hot water tank becomes a store: spare electricity in, hot water out.

What’s good about it:

  • It’s a small device, quick to fit, and far cheaper than a battery.
  • Almost every house already has a hot water tank to store energy in.
  • On a sunny day it can heat a full tank, so you don’t use gas, oil or night-rate electricity to do it.

Its limits:

  • Once the tank is hot, it’s full. A diverter can’t store more than the tank holds.
  • It only helps with hot water. It does nothing for lights, cooking, the TV or the car in the evening.
  • If a heat pump already heats your water, a diverter is usually less useful, because a heat pump heats water far more efficiently than an immersion.

How a battery works

A battery stores surplus electricity and gives it back when the house needs it, usually in the evening when the panels have stopped. That covers everything that runs on electricity, not just hot water.

What’s good about it:

  • It covers your evening use: cooking, lights, TV, the kettle.
  • It can also be set to charge from a cheap night rate and discharge at the expensive peak, which helps even in winter, when there’s little solar to store.
  • The SEAI grant pays €600 towards a battery of 5 kWh or more, on top of up to €1,800 for the panels, so up to €2,400 for a home. You can also claim it for a battery on its own if you already have panels.

Its limits:

  • It costs considerably more than a diverter.
  • Its value depends on your evening usage. If you use little in the evening, a big battery sits half-empty.
  • Batteries lose a little capacity over the years, which manufacturers warrant against.

Which homes suit which

Which homes suit a battery and which suit a hot water diverter
Your homeUsually the better first step
Out all day, big evening usageBattery
Electric immersion or night-rate hot water, small budgetDiverter
Heat pump heats the waterBattery (a diverter adds little)
Electric car charged at homeBattery with a smart charger, or a charger that follows solar
Oil or gas boiler, and you want to use less of it in summerDiverter
Plenty of surplus and a bigger budgetBoth

Can you have both?

Yes. Many systems use both: the battery fills first for the evening, and the diverter takes whatever is left to heat water. The system decides the order, so nothing is wasted.

And sometimes the answer is neither

If your house uses most of its solar as it’s made (someone home all day, a business running through daylight, a farm with cooling and pumps), there may be very little surplus to save. Then neither device earns its keep, and we’ll say so.

We size batteries from your actual usage, not the biggest one that fits. Get a free survey and we’ll show you what your surplus really is. Or read more about battery storage.

From the blog

More from the blog

All articles

Get started

Start with a free site survey

Tell us about your property and we’ll arrange a free site survey. There’s no charge and no obligation.

Get a free quoteCall (090) 640 0180

Mon–Fri, 9am–5pm · Free site survey